Subscribe for updates
Recent Posts
- Federal Court Rejects EPA Attempt to Dismiss Clean Air Act Citizen Suit Against xAI Data Center
- Idaho District Court Reiterates Distinction Between Remedial and Removal Actions Under CERCLA
- D.C. Circuit Rejects Challenge to EPA’s Designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA Hazardous Substances
- Tenth Circuit Clarifies Diligent Prosecution Bar to Citizen Suits under Clean Air Act
- Eleventh Circuit Allows Federal Officer Removal for EPA-Directed Cleanup
Topics
- Data Centers
- State Implementation Plans
- Venue
- NJDEP
- Pollutants
- Connecticut
- Federal Land Policy and Management Act
- Loper Bright
- Agency Action
- Council on Environmental Quality
- Public Trust Doctrine
- New Jersey Civil Rights Act
- Environmental Justice
- Disparate Impact
- Title VI
- Massachusetts
- Evidence
- Internal Investigation
- Citizens Suit
- Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act
- Georgia
- FIFRA
- Major Questions Doctrine
- Lead Paint
- Greenwashing
- Good Faith Settlement
- Federal Facilities
- Statutory Notice
- Oil Pollution Act
- Federal Jurisdiction
- Owner Liability
- Court of Federal Claims
- Ripeness
- Renewable Fuel Standard
- Fish and Wildlife Service
- Greenhouse Gas
- Refinery
- Alaska
- Florida
- Solvents
- National Priorities List
- Vapor Intrusion
- Price-Anderson Act
- Solid Waste Management Act
- Successor Liability
- Personal Jurisdiction
- Operator Liability
- Potentially Responsible Parties
- Federal Circuit
- Environmental Covenants
- Apportionment
- National Contingency Plan
- Divisibility
- Water Pollution Control Act
- Strict Liability
- Historic Resources
- Public Utilities Commission
- Utilities
- Hydraulic Fracturing
- Water Use
- Ohio
- PFAS
- Arbitration
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Climate Change
- Auer Deference
- Commonwealth Court
- Fees
- West Virginia
- Forest Service
- TSCA
- Asbestos
- Martime
- Gold King Mine
- Federal Tort Claims Act
- New Mexico
- Utah
- Tribal Lands
- Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control
- Delaware
- National Forest Management Act
- FERC
- Endangered Species Act
- Chevron Deference
- United States Supreme Court
- HSCA
- Corporate Veil
- Alter Ego
- Allocation
- Eleventh Amendment
- Delaware River Basin Commission
- Mining
- Intervention
- New Hampshire
- Building Materials
- Property Damage
- First Circuit
- PCBs
- Groundwater
- Natural Resource Damages
- Brownfield
- Brownfields
- Innocent Party
- Environmental Rights Amendment
- PHMSA
- Pipeline Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
- FOIA
- Effluents
- Sediment Sites
- EHB
- Texas
- Missouri
- Pipelines
- Injunction
- Coal Ash
- Spoliation
- TMDL
- Stormwater
- Safe Drinking Water Act
- Colorado
- Michigan
- Drinking Water
- North Carolina
- Bankruptcy
- Civil Penalties
- Clean Streams Law
- Hearing Board
- Arranger Liability
- Retroactive
- Sovereign Immunity
- Stigma
- Fair Market Value
- Damages
- Tax assessment
- Property Value
- Storage Tank
- Indemnification
- Energy
- Fifth Circuit
- Electric
- Arizona
- Ninth Circuit
- Attorney-Client
- OPRA
- Iowa
- Discovery Rule
- Fourth Circuit
- Eighth Circuit
- Administrative Appeals
- Taxes
- Preemption
- CAFA
- Procedure
- Contamination
- Natural Gas
- Residential
- Inspection
- Freshwater Wetlands Protect Act
- New York
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
- Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection
- Natural Gas Act
- D.C. Circuit
- Mercury
- HAPs
- Hazardous Air Pollutants
- Condemnation
- Takings
- Storage
- Fifth Amendment
- Flooding
- Takings Clause
- Causation
- Spill Act
- NEPA
- Interior
- Mineral Leasing Act
- Tenth Circuit
- California
- Act 13
- Zoning
- Duty to Defend
- Insurance Coverage
- Landfill
- Eminent Domain
- Sixth Circuit
- Private Right of Action
- Illinois
- Water
- Diligent Prosecution
- Subject Matter Jurisdiction
- Citizen Suit
- Arkansas
- Pennsylvania
- Press
- Uncategorized
- Maryland
- Eleventh Circuit
- Navigability
- Montana
- Equal-Footing Doctrine
- Riverbed
- Seventh Circuit
- Indiana
- Breach of Contract
- Public Lands
- Green House Counsel
- Bona Fide Prospective Purchaser
- Rulemaking
- Delay Notice
- Equity
- Enforcement
- Laches
- CISWI
- Consent Decree
- Boiler MACT
- EPA
- Declaratory Relief
- Contribution
- Second Circuit
- NPDES
- Standing
- Medical Monitoring
- Dimock
- Case Update
- Legislation
- Louisiana
- Certification
- Dukes
- CLE
- Decisions of Note
- Privilege
- Work Product
- Expert Witness
- Cases to Watch
- Discovery
- Defense Costs
- Insurance
- Remediation
- Response Action Contractors
- Consultant Liability
- Negligence
- Donovan
- Army Corps
- Rapanos
- Hog Barn
- Trespass
- Odors
- Class Actions
- Kentucky
- Farming
- Nuisance
- Informal Agency Action
- ISRA
- New Jersey
- Administrative Hearing
- Combustion
- Air
- Emissions
- Waste
- RCRA
- Railroad
- Cancer
- CERCLA
- Speaking Engagements
- Third Circuit
- Removal
- Toxic Torts
- Federal Procedure
- Permits
- Title V
- Clean Air Act
- Statute of Limitations
- Superfund
- Cost Recovery
- Cleanup
- Supreme Court
- Tolling
- Statute of Repose
- Multi-District Litigation
- Camp Lejeune
- Clean Water Act
- Due Process
- Marcellus Shale
- Deeds
- Wetlands
- Mineral Rights
- Enforcement Action
- Administrative Procedures Act
- Real Estate
- Exploration
- Drilling
- Leases
- Oil and Gas
- Royalties
Blog editor
Blog Contributors
Counsel and courts continue to adapt to the “new world” of class certification following the United States Supreme Court decision in Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, and the recent case of Ratner v. Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products, LP, Case No. SU11CV343-W (Effingham County Ga. July 5, 2012), is a good example.
The facts of the case are typical of the breed – a group of homeowners in Effingham County, Georgia have sued Georgia-Pacific for property damages allegedly caused by the release of hydrogen sulfide gas from a nearby paper manufacturing plant. And, plaintiffs filed the suit as a putative class action. What makes the case interesting, though, is how the class is defined, and how that definition has resulted in one of the few post-Dukes class certifications of its kind.
The plaintiffs in Ratner are:
All citizens of the State of Georgia who, as of November 18, 2010, owned property lying, in whole or in part, within an area of land lying in Effingham County, George, and bounded [by precise metes and bounds, except] the above-named Defendant, its related corporations and all directors, officers and employees of the Defendant.
Notable is that the class is limited only to property owners as of one particular date in a carefully defined geographic area. In other words, the class definition avoids many of the pitfalls that have doomed other classes, such as the one we discussed inour post on the Louisiana case of Price v. Roy R. Martin, where the rejected class had been defined as “past and present owners” as well as people “physically present” in a 1-1/2 mile radius of the facility, which had gone through several owners.
With the definition given, the Georgia court found that all elements of its state law equivalent of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a) and 23(b)(3) had been met. The Court found that class members could be readily ascertained from public records and, with only one defendant, issues of liability, available remedies and punitive damages would predominate over any individualized questions that may exist related to the amount of damages. In a nod to the experience of counsel (and maybe a wink as well), the Court also noted “that counsel for Plaintiffs and for the Defendant have extensive experience in representation of parties in class actions adjudicating claims brought on behalf of property owners for damage caused by releases of hazardous chemicals, and that these cases have been managed to a final conclusion.”
