Subscribe for updates
Recent Posts
- Federal Court Rejects EPA Attempt to Dismiss Clean Air Act Citizen Suit Against xAI Data Center
- Idaho District Court Reiterates Distinction Between Remedial and Removal Actions Under CERCLA
- D.C. Circuit Rejects Challenge to EPA’s Designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA Hazardous Substances
- Tenth Circuit Clarifies Diligent Prosecution Bar to Citizen Suits under Clean Air Act
- Eleventh Circuit Allows Federal Officer Removal for EPA-Directed Cleanup
Topics
- Data Centers
- State Implementation Plans
- Venue
- NJDEP
- Pollutants
- Connecticut
- Federal Land Policy and Management Act
- Loper Bright
- Agency Action
- Council on Environmental Quality
- Public Trust Doctrine
- New Jersey Civil Rights Act
- Title VI
- Environmental Justice
- Disparate Impact
- Massachusetts
- Internal Investigation
- Evidence
- Citizens Suit
- Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act
- Georgia
- FIFRA
- Major Questions Doctrine
- Lead Paint
- Greenwashing
- Good Faith Settlement
- Federal Facilities
- Statutory Notice
- Oil Pollution Act
- Federal Jurisdiction
- Owner Liability
- Court of Federal Claims
- Ripeness
- Renewable Fuel Standard
- Fish and Wildlife Service
- Greenhouse Gas
- Refinery
- Alaska
- Florida
- National Priorities List
- Vapor Intrusion
- Solvents
- Price-Anderson Act
- Solid Waste Management Act
- Successor Liability
- Personal Jurisdiction
- Operator Liability
- Potentially Responsible Parties
- Environmental Covenants
- Federal Circuit
- Divisibility
- Apportionment
- National Contingency Plan
- Water Pollution Control Act
- Strict Liability
- Utilities
- Historic Resources
- Public Utilities Commission
- Hydraulic Fracturing
- Water Use
- Ohio
- PFAS
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Arbitration
- Climate Change
- Auer Deference
- Commonwealth Court
- Fees
- West Virginia
- Forest Service
- TSCA
- Asbestos
- Martime
- Gold King Mine
- Utah
- Tribal Lands
- Federal Tort Claims Act
- New Mexico
- Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control
- Delaware
- National Forest Management Act
- FERC
- Endangered Species Act
- Chevron Deference
- United States Supreme Court
- HSCA
- Corporate Veil
- Alter Ego
- Allocation
- Eleventh Amendment
- Delaware River Basin Commission
- Mining
- Intervention
- New Hampshire
- PCBs
- Building Materials
- Property Damage
- First Circuit
- Groundwater
- Natural Resource Damages
- Innocent Party
- Brownfield
- Brownfields
- Environmental Rights Amendment
- PHMSA
- Pipeline Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
- FOIA
- Effluents
- Sediment Sites
- EHB
- Texas
- Missouri
- Pipelines
- Injunction
- Coal Ash
- Spoliation
- Stormwater
- TMDL
- Safe Drinking Water Act
- Colorado
- Drinking Water
- Michigan
- North Carolina
- Bankruptcy
- Civil Penalties
- Clean Streams Law
- Hearing Board
- Arranger Liability
- Retroactive
- Sovereign Immunity
- Stigma
- Fair Market Value
- Damages
- Tax assessment
- Property Value
- Storage Tank
- Indemnification
- Energy
- Fifth Circuit
- Electric
- Arizona
- Ninth Circuit
- Attorney-Client
- OPRA
- Iowa
- Discovery Rule
- Fourth Circuit
- Eighth Circuit
- Administrative Appeals
- Taxes
- Preemption
- CAFA
- Natural Gas
- Procedure
- Contamination
- Freshwater Wetlands Protect Act
- Residential
- Inspection
- New York
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
- Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection
- Natural Gas Act
- Hazardous Air Pollutants
- D.C. Circuit
- Mercury
- HAPs
- Condemnation
- Takings
- Storage
- Flooding
- Takings Clause
- Fifth Amendment
- Causation
- Spill Act
- NEPA
- Interior
- Mineral Leasing Act
- Tenth Circuit
- California
- Zoning
- Act 13
- Insurance Coverage
- Duty to Defend
- Landfill
- Eminent Domain
- Private Right of Action
- Sixth Circuit
- Water
- Illinois
- Diligent Prosecution
- Subject Matter Jurisdiction
- Citizen Suit
- Arkansas
- Pennsylvania
- Press
- Uncategorized
- Maryland
- Eleventh Circuit
- Riverbed
- Navigability
- Montana
- Equal-Footing Doctrine
- Seventh Circuit
- Indiana
- Breach of Contract
- Public Lands
- Green House Counsel
- Bona Fide Prospective Purchaser
- Boiler MACT
- EPA
- Rulemaking
- Delay Notice
- Equity
- Enforcement
- Laches
- CISWI
- Consent Decree
- Declaratory Relief
- Contribution
- Second Circuit
- Standing
- NPDES
- Medical Monitoring
- Dimock
- Case Update
- Legislation
- Dukes
- Certification
- Louisiana
- CLE
- Discovery
- Decisions of Note
- Cases to Watch
- Privilege
- Expert Witness
- Work Product
- Defense Costs
- Insurance
- Consultant Liability
- Negligence
- Remediation
- Response Action Contractors
- Rapanos
- Donovan
- Army Corps
- Hog Barn
- Trespass
- Class Actions
- Odors
- Kentucky
- Farming
- Nuisance
- Informal Agency Action
- ISRA
- New Jersey
- Administrative Hearing
- RCRA
- Railroad
- Cancer
- Combustion
- Emissions
- Air
- Waste
- Speaking Engagements
- CERCLA
- Removal
- Federal Procedure
- Toxic Torts
- Third Circuit
- Permits
- Title V
- Clean Air Act
- Statute of Limitations
- Cost Recovery
- Cleanup
- Supreme Court
- Superfund
- Camp Lejeune
- Tolling
- Statute of Repose
- Multi-District Litigation
- Administrative Procedures Act
- Deeds
- Wetlands
- Clean Water Act
- Due Process
- Mineral Rights
- Enforcement Action
- Marcellus Shale
- Exploration
- Drilling
- Leases
- Oil and Gas
- Royalties
- Real Estate
Blog editor
Blog Contributors
On April 24, 2018, the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board issued a decision denying a Petition for Supersedeas filed by Center for Coalfield Justice and Sierra Club which had sought to enjoin Consol Pennsylvania Coal Company, LLC (“Consol”) from mining under a stream called Polen Run located in Ryerson Station State Park See Center for Coalfield Justice v. DEP, EHB Docket No. 2018-028-R (Opinion issued Apr. 24, 2018) (“CCJ III”). The Board’s opinion reinforces the Board’s prior decisions applying Article I, Section 27 of the Pennsylvania Constitution (“Environmental Rights Amendment” or “ERA”) in the context of a permitting decision in light of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision in Pa. Environmental Defense Found. v. Commonwealth, 161 A.3d 911 (Pa. 2017) (“PEDF”).
In a prior decision issued by the Board involving Consol’s longwall mining operations in the area known as the Bailey Mine East Expansion Area, as we reported here, the Board struck down one permit revision (No. 189), finding that it violated the Clean Streams Law (“CSL”) and the Bituminous Mine Subsidence and Land Conservation Act (“Mine Subsidence Act”), and therefore also violated the ERA, but upheld another permit revision (No. 180), finding that it did not violate the CSL or the Mine Subsidence Act and also did not violate the ERA. See Center for Coalfield Justice v. DEP, EHB Docket No. 2014-072-B (Adjudication issued Aug. 15, 2017) (“CCJ II”). Interestingly, Revision No. 189, which was struck down in CCJ II, had authorized longwall mining under Polen Run, the same permitted activity CCJ III approved, whereas Revision No. 180, which was upheld, did not. What changed was not the activity, but the evidence presented regarding environmental impacts.
In the Board’s more recent decision in CCJ III, the Board allowed Consol to proceed with longwall mining under Polen Run under a new permit revision (No. 210) after finding that the stream is not likely to be impaired and, should any flow loss occur, it can be successfully restored. Specifically, the Board found that, while it is possible that grouting could result in the impairment of a stream and therefore violate the ERA, the evidence presented before the Board indicated that grouting would only be required in small sections of the stream, if at all, that any such flow loss will be minimal and short-lived and restored with the restoration techniques authorized by the permit revision, and that the actual effects on the stream and Ryerson Station State Park will not be noticeable and will not interfere with the use of the park by the public.
Although the Board’s prior decision in CCJ II set forth the standards for complying with the ERA in the context of a permit action, that decision should now be read in tandem with CCJ III. While the primary rules and principles established in CCJ II remain intact, CCJ III adds a layer of factual analysis and legal interpretation over CCJ II and reinforces the importance of expert testimony in demonstrating compliance with the ERA.
